Should we stop cleaning surfaces?

Should we stop cleaning surfaces?

There is an opinion that perhaps we should stop cleaning surfaces.  Recent NY Times article.

We respectfully disagree.

This is similar to saying we should not wash our hands or we should reduce hygiene.  We think the problem has more to do with the excessive use of toxic chemicals (yes, chemicals in concentrations are toxic).  We do not recommend UV Ultra-Violet because the damage effects of UV on human tissues and cells are cumulative.

We recommend steam.  Why Steam?  

Can biofilms be eliminated with steam – a bit of antimicrobial trivia included?

Why are the SaniZap® Generators more Efficient than Boiler type of Steam Generators?

Compare Energy Savings with Rapid Steam Techniques to remove grime and dirt.  

The History of Hygiene and Sanitation

How does one measure the hygienic quality or cleanliness of a surface or object.  What does clean mean.

How does one measure the hygienic quality or cleanliness of a surface or object. What does clean mean.

Can we quantify cleanliness? What is ATP?

This is commonly measured by an ATP (Adenosine Triphosphate) test-meter that measures RLU’s  (Relative Light Units) from swabbed regions. The number and types of bacteria present on a surface is of concern for  infection control, but bacterial tests are sometimes very specific and do not yield the overall hygienic condition or cleanliness of a surface.  RLU measurements on the other hand are more appropriate to define general cleanliness.  ATP is a molecule found in and around living cells, and as such it gives a direct measure of biological concentration and health. ATP (adenosine triphosphate) is a molecule made up of an adenine ring, a ribose sugar, and most importantly 3 phosphates. In the most basic terms, this molecule is the body’s currency for all of its functions. Anything that the body does requires energy which all comes from ATP.The fats, carbs, and proteins that we eat are broken down and metabolized in order to replenish the used ATP in our bodies. One of the phosphates breaks off and releases a burst of energy. When this happens the molecule turns into ADP (adenosine diphosphate) because there is only 2 phosphates attached. Through a series of reactions another phosphate is attached and the molecule becomes ATP again. The ATP in our bodies are recycled after they produce energy.

ATP is quantified by measuring the light produced through its reaction with the naturally occurring enzyme luciferase using a luminometer. The amount of light produced is directly proportional to the amount of ATP present in a sample.

What Is CFU and what is RLU?   In microbiology, a colony-forming unit (CFU) is used to estimate the number of viable bacteria or fungal cells in a sample. Colony-forming units are used to quantify results in many microbiological plating and counting methods. The CFU count is an estimate of the number of cells present, as the only cells able to form colonies are those that can grow under the conditions of the test.  See comparisons in many textbooks or in articles like Antimicrobial and Anti-Corrosive Efficacy of Inorganic Nano Porous Surfaces, Clean Technologies and Environmental Policies (CTEP), 845–857 (2017).
RLU (Relative Light Units) is the unit for measuring the ATP (Adenosine Triphosphate).   ATP has been found to be a sensitive indicator molecule for the presence of biological residues due to its universal presence in all living cells (microbes, animal and plant cells).  When a test swab is activated, a bio-luminescent reaction occurs, generating light output.  RLU measurements will vary for the type of meter. However, because the ATP bio-luminescence reaction is linear, the more ATP present, the higher the contamination- indicates poor hygiene and vice versa. The presence of ATP on the surface indicates that it has not been adequately cleaned.   An increase in “dirt” (mostly biological residues) on a surface is displayed in an increase in the amount of ATP present on that surface.  Thus ATP an effective marker for the assessment of the hygienic status of an environmental surface.  RLU’s measure this ATP.
ATP tests (the RLU measurements) are not intended to replace microbial tests but there is often a direct correlation between the results of the two types of measurements when done concurrently.
It is a common mistake for users to expect a close agreement between RLU measurements when comparing different systems (different makes of RLU measurement meters). This is due to the differences in RLU sensitivity, scales and outputs and the inherent variation of this biological assay and variations from  sample distribution and sample collection.   Therefore the ATP hygiene test (RLU counts) should not be considered as a precision assay for bacterial counts. The ATP hygiene test application is a sensitive, direct, objective test of cleaning efficiency and risk.  It is a quick risk analyzer that help you suspect if there is a need to do further laboratory tests for a more detailed test for bacteria and particular species of bacteria.  Care should be taken when comparing the system performance from different instruments or suppliers.  Comparisons ahould be made with the same test machines and conditions.
The RLU measurements are great to infer if the cleanliness quality of a test surface or object  has changed or if a particular cleaning system has efficacy in improving cleanliness.   It is not a quantitative test for bacterial counts as it indicates different information than a CFU count test does.
When using RLU it is common to define a threshold of cleanliness.  This is subjective in the sense that it depends on the machine employed. In fact some studies show that there is poor correlation between active bacteria and ATP measurements. ( Colbert et. al. Healthcare Infection, 2015,20, 108–114 Research,  However this test is used often.
Here is a chart from A suggested sampling algorithm for use with ATP testing for cleanliness measurement  (by G.S. Whiteley, T.O. Glasbey, P.P. Fahey, Volume 21, ISSUE 4, P169-175, December 01, 2016
Suggested cleanliness thresholds and corresponding RLU for 3 ATP device brands.
Cleanliness thresholdHygiena MachineCleantrace MachineKikkoman Machine
Initial cleanliness thresholdTC1100 RLU500 RLU460 RLU
Secondary cleanliness thresholdTC250 RLU250 RLU230 RLU
Tertiary cleanliness thresholdTC325 RLU125 RLU115 RLU
Lower Limit of QuantitationLLQ0 RLU100 RLU90 RLU
Last Page Vol. 3A

Last Page Vol. 3A

Levels of Cleaning in Normal Establishments.  Reduce microbes, mites, fleas and bed-bugs with good steam. (Rental Cars, Motels and Restaurants).

Levels of Cleaning in Normal Establishments. Reduce microbes, mites, fleas and bed-bugs with good steam. (Rental Cars, Motels and Restaurants).

The levels of clean

In a restaurant, there are at least three levels of cleaning: cleaning, sanitizing, and disinfecting and deep-cleaning.  At the lowest level, cleaning means clearing dirt, trash, and debris from surfaces with a cloth. This makes the room and serving area look tidy and inviting, but it may not be enough to protect your guests. When done correctly, sanitizing kills 99% of bacteria, fungi, and some microbes. Sanitizing solutions must be mixed at the proper concentration and must be left on a surface for at least 60 seconds preferably more (but be aware of toxic chemicals). If you wipe down a table, menu, or serving counter with sanitizer and immediately dry it, you won’t get the full effect- you have to leave it there for minutes depending on the solution and dilution. Make sure your sanitizer does not cause corrosion. The highest level is sterility or close to ii is a good target.  Some types of steam from rapid steam generators at high temperatures can get you there.  But be careful not to burn anything.  It is highly recommended that you work with a microbiologist if you wish these levels of cleaning. Be aware that sanitizers can cause damage.  People use cloth or towels made of organic materials such as cotton or paper pulp. These materials break down sanitizer and will, over time, cause the solution to be ineffective.  Rental Cars should be properly steamed with MightySteam for adequate residence.

High temperature steam like those obtained from SaniZap® act within a second to few seconds.

Use the cleanest possible methods for good hygiene.  Routine cleaning and disinfecting are an important part of reducing the risk of exposure to COVID-19. Normal routine cleaning with soap and water alone can reduce risk of exposure and is a necessary step before you disinfect dirty surfaces.

Surfaces frequently touched by multiple people, such as door handles, desks, phones, light switches, and faucets, should be cleaned and disinfected at least daily. More frequent cleaning and disinfection may be required based on level of use.  Source  For more information on Restaurants

One problem of using some type of sugar based chemicals are that it attracts not only microbes but also small creatures (bed bugs and ants).  High temperature steam like the MightySteam® works on both microbes and bugs.

Hard To Reach Biofilms

Hard To Reach Biofilms